Nick's 1991 200q Project - QUAT44RO

Document and share your build!
Hank
Posts: 1718
Joined: Tue Feb 26, 2013 1:16 am

Re: Nick's 1991 200q Project - QUAT44RO

Post by Hank »

Static flow numbers are only part of the equation. You are getting a fabulous reading at various amounts of lift on the valve, but the story of how long it is at those lifts is not completely told. With a roller rocker cam, you can ramp up and ramp down at extremely steeper angles. This amounts to about 25-30% more flow when you are not playing "keep the cam on the bucket" routine with a bucket over valve design.

You can see this with the cams below

Image

The left is 07k and the right is 7a. Now remember, the 07k is a ratio'ed rocker arm, so height of lobe can't be really considered, but what is interesting is the ramp up angle and the duration on the cam. It basically paints the picture of why a roller rocker is the bee's knees.

On a side note, pistons are shipping out as we speak!

Hank
User avatar
chaloux
Posts: 3167
Joined: Wed Feb 27, 2013 11:43 am
Location: Muskoka, Ontario, Canada

Re: Nick's 1991 200q Project - QUAT44RO

Post by chaloux »

Fuckin' told you guys

LOL
Matt

18 Silverado 1500 work pig, roof rack and tonneau cover
11 Jetta sedan TDI DSG, rear muffler delete
GONE :( 87 4ktq - 4 FOX SNAKES

Image
2.5TYPE44
Posts: 461
Joined: Tue Mar 05, 2013 5:31 pm

Re: Nick's 1991 200q Project - QUAT44RO

Post by 2.5TYPE44 »

Don't worry, I'm sure you will be more than happy and impressed with your built "old school,junky,non 07k boat anchor" :-) At this point you might as well give up and go 07k. I know someone who would love to accept your scrap iron of a 5 cylinder motor you have going on. ;)
User avatar
chaloux
Posts: 3167
Joined: Wed Feb 27, 2013 11:43 am
Location: Muskoka, Ontario, Canada

Re: Nick's 1991 200q Project - QUAT44RO

Post by chaloux »

May as well just give it away!
Matt

18 Silverado 1500 work pig, roof rack and tonneau cover
11 Jetta sedan TDI DSG, rear muffler delete
GONE :( 87 4ktq - 4 FOX SNAKES

Image
2.5TYPE44
Posts: 461
Joined: Tue Mar 05, 2013 5:31 pm

Re: Nick's 1991 200q Project - QUAT44RO

Post by 2.5TYPE44 »

Yep! I'll even pay for the shipping. Jeff can just crate it all up and ship it my way. Might as well throw the clutch in with it. :rofl:
User avatar
themagellan
Posts: 873
Joined: Tue Mar 05, 2013 10:36 am

Re: Nick's 1991 200q Project - QUAT44RO

Post by themagellan »

Amazing looking at even the difference in quality of metal. Getting hard to rationalize big power from a 3b/aan in a certain price bracket vs the 07K


Oh, and....

Image
User avatar
pilihp2
Posts: 1106
Joined: Fri Mar 01, 2013 2:18 am
Location: Reno, Nv

Re: Nick's 1991 200q Project - QUAT44RO

Post by pilihp2 »

themagellan wrote:Amazing looking at even the difference in quality of metal. Getting hard to rationalize big power from a 3b/aan in a certain price bracket vs the 07K


Oh, and....

Image



I just died

I literally am dead.


Oh god.
-Phil
87 5ktq - 20vt
91 v8 5spd - Why?
05 S4 - Gone and very much so forgotten
14 TDI Touareg

-Terrible at responding to PM's
User avatar
chaloux
Posts: 3167
Joined: Wed Feb 27, 2013 11:43 am
Location: Muskoka, Ontario, Canada

Re: Nick's 1991 200q Project - QUAT44RO

Post by chaloux »

New avatar
Matt

18 Silverado 1500 work pig, roof rack and tonneau cover
11 Jetta sedan TDI DSG, rear muffler delete
GONE :( 87 4ktq - 4 FOX SNAKES

Image
User avatar
loxxrider
Posts: 6642
Joined: Wed Feb 27, 2013 7:46 am
Location: Jupiter, FL / Somewhere, PA

Re: Nick's 1991 200q Project - QUAT44RO

Post by loxxrider »

themagellan wrote:Amazing looking at even the difference in quality of metal. Getting hard to rationalize big power from a 3b/aan in a certain price bracket vs the 07K


Oh, and....

Image


Quality of metal? I think you are just looking at a different design, not different/better metallurgy.
-Chris

'91 Audi 200 20v - Revver/BAT project
'91 Audi 200 20v Avant
'01 Anthracite M5
'90 M3
'85 Euro 635csi
'12 X3
E34 530i (maybe rear-mount soon)
Colin2750
Posts: 95
Joined: Thu Feb 28, 2013 9:08 pm

Re: Nick's 1991 200q Project - QUAT44RO

Post by Colin2750 »

themagellan wrote:Amazing looking at even the difference in quality of metal. Getting hard to rationalize big power from a 3b/aan in a certain price bracket vs the 07K


One is cast while the other is not. It's also hollow, for more lightness and other fun things. :we:
Hank
Posts: 1718
Joined: Tue Feb 26, 2013 1:16 am

Re: Nick's 1991 200q Project - QUAT44RO

Post by Hank »

LOL

Well done.

You can get 07k flow out of an older AAN based, it just turns into a six thousand dollar head before you realize what happened to you :) Right Nick? 6 thousand dollars can buy a lot of adapter parts, lots of labor and lots of spare 500$ 07k's when tuning doesn't go as planned :)

Hank
Dutchbroracer
Posts: 167
Joined: Thu Mar 14, 2013 1:43 am
Location: California

Re: Nick's 1991 200q Project - QUAT44RO

Post by Dutchbroracer »

Hank wrote:LOL

Well done.

You can get 07k flow out of an older AAN based, it just turns into a six thousand dollar head before you realize what happened to you :) Right Nick? 6 thousand dollars can buy a lot of adapter parts, lots of labor and lots of spare 500$ 07k's when tuning doesn't go as planned :)

Hank


Holy balls..I'm so poor.
Jared

91 200 20vt
01 B5 A4 1.8t
Image
User avatar
vt10vt
Posts: 1021
Joined: Sun Mar 10, 2013 9:44 pm
Location: Winooski, VT

Re: Nick's 1991 200q Project - QUAT44RO

Post by vt10vt »

Dutchbroracer wrote:
Hank wrote:LOL

Well done.

You can get 07k flow out of an older AAN based, it just turns into a six thousand dollar head before you realize what happened to you :) Right Nick? 6 thousand dollars can buy a lot of adapter parts, lots of labor and lots of spare 500$ 07k's when tuning doesn't go as planned :)

Hank


Holy balls..I'm so poor.

:metoo: I'd have been happy SS exhaust valves lol
-Shawn C.
2001 S4 6spd Avant blk/blk - stock daily
2002 01E B6 A4 Built FYF, Built 1.8T, HX35 ~330whp
1989 MC-1 200 Avant- MS1 -Gone but will never forget her lessons
1987 5ktq Sedan - Best $500 beater ever
2.5TYPE44
Posts: 461
Joined: Tue Mar 05, 2013 5:31 pm

Re: Nick's 1991 200q Project - QUAT44RO

Post by 2.5TYPE44 »

$6,000.00 for your cylinder head...? :o are you running titanium lifters, valves, and cams?
User avatar
loxxrider
Posts: 6642
Joined: Wed Feb 27, 2013 7:46 am
Location: Jupiter, FL / Somewhere, PA

Re: Nick's 1991 200q Project - QUAT44RO

Post by loxxrider »

Cams alone are $1500 retail... The check I wrote for the components you listed MINUS cams was still over ~$1k. So you're talking $2500 just in components potentially, plus however many man hours the port job requires. For a development head I'd think that number is in the hundreds. For a regular head I'd think it is at least 30-40 if done by someone experienced with the exact procedure. Not to mention the work required to clearance the combustion chambers for supersized valves, etc.

At shop rates, it is easy for me to understand where that number comes from.
-Chris

'91 Audi 200 20v - Revver/BAT project
'91 Audi 200 20v Avant
'01 Anthracite M5
'90 M3
'85 Euro 635csi
'12 X3
E34 530i (maybe rear-mount soon)
2.5TYPE44
Posts: 461
Joined: Tue Mar 05, 2013 5:31 pm

Re: Nick's 1991 200q Project - QUAT44RO

Post by 2.5TYPE44 »

Thank goodness I didn't do a development head and went with oversized valves instead of super sized valves. I got cheap off the shelf Cat cams too at about 799.00 It helped to keep the cost down or Jeff gave me the hook up on everything.
Hank
Posts: 1718
Joined: Tue Feb 26, 2013 1:16 am

Re: Nick's 1991 200q Project - QUAT44RO

Post by Hank »

To match the flow of an 07k with all things considered, you would likely have a 30-40 hour port job@ 80-100$/HR by somebody professional like Jeff on a bench
1200$ CATs
300$ valve springs
250$ Ti Retainers
400$ in valves
75 in decking
250 in adjustable cam gear
50 hot tank
Core(7a modified to turbo spec, around 400$, AAN in useable shape, around 450$)

If you get ambitious with the cams and have to have solids to match the 9300rpm rev potential of the 07k, you are talking another 500$ in solid lifters and several hours of shimming, along with the 750$ Ferrea Valve Springs required to get over 13.5mm worth of lift instead of the 300$ supertech ones.

Heads add up VERY quickly, which is the reason the 07k is such a cool idea. Basically all that cost above on ebay for 200 BIN, but about 1800$ worth of adapters/pans/flywheel and another 2000 in manifolds.
User avatar
Mcstiff
Posts: 2003
Joined: Wed Feb 27, 2013 4:16 pm
Location: Erie, CO

Re: Nick's 1991 200q Project - QUAT44RO

Post by Mcstiff »

And the 07k still has headroom for better cams, valves, and porting; of course that doubles your investment but if you put 4k into a urI5 head what's next?

I have a spreadsheet comparing the cost of an AAN with Rods (stock head) and an 07K build; the 07K is more money but part of that is because I have this AAN longblock that I can't seem to give away :lol:
User avatar
mushasho
Posts: 1036
Joined: Wed Feb 27, 2013 1:09 pm
Location: North of Boston, MA

Re: Nick's 1991 200q Project - QUAT44RO

Post by mushasho »

Mcstiff wrote:I have a spreadsheet comparing the cost of an AAN with Rods (stock head) and an 07K build; the 07K is more money but part of that is because I have this AAN longblock that I can't seem to give away :lol:


that's really only further skewed by the fact that the 07k also requires pistons, something not added on your AAN build...
UglyUr 2.5L 95.5mm Stroker
Image
Rubi PTE6062 Gen 2 Screamer
Image
Hank
Posts: 1718
Joined: Tue Feb 26, 2013 1:16 am

Re: Nick's 1991 200q Project - QUAT44RO

Post by Hank »

All things aside, the real benefit comes if the unthinkable happens. Drop a valve on a 700whp I5, you are out 7-10 grand. Do it on a built 07k, you are out 2-3 grand.
User avatar
amd is the best
Posts: 1431
Joined: Wed Feb 27, 2013 12:25 am
Location: Schenectady, NY

Re: Nick's 1991 200q Project - QUAT44RO

Post by amd is the best »

ANYWAY, this car will be a 3B. We can go back and forth all day but ultimately I wanted to keep the old SHITTY engine with a poor lifter design, pay "TONS" of money to only SLIGHTLY outflow (possibly) the $500 junkyard counterpart and we'll see how my horrible choices pan out. Turbo is probably "too big" too.

For the record, the head didn't cost $6000... To give real rough figures we'll say the parts cost ~$1500 (no CATS) and the labor was ~$1500 and I shopped around for the CATS and scored them at $1000. So I'm around $4000 give or take for a completely built cylinder head with REAL cams (7A's are a joke in comparison). All work was performed by a trusted individual with a reputation to produce reliable performance and longevity. I would have paid double for the labor knowing that it was done correctly.
Nick

'00 A4 1.8t
'91 200 20v
'91 200 20v Avant
http://www.youtube.com/amdisthebest
User avatar
chaloux
Posts: 3167
Joined: Wed Feb 27, 2013 11:43 am
Location: Muskoka, Ontario, Canada

Re: Nick's 1991 200q Project - QUAT44RO

Post by chaloux »

amd is the best wrote:ANYWAY, this car will be a 3B. We can go back and forth all day but ultimately I wanted to keep the old SHITTY engine with a poor lifter design, pay "TONS" of money to only SLIGHTLY outflow (possibly) the $500 junkyard counterpart and we'll see how my horrible choices pan out. Turbo is probably "too big" too.


:rofl:
Matt

18 Silverado 1500 work pig, roof rack and tonneau cover
11 Jetta sedan TDI DSG, rear muffler delete
GONE :( 87 4ktq - 4 FOX SNAKES

Image
User avatar
ringbearer
Posts: 1282
Joined: Wed Feb 27, 2013 12:50 pm
Location: Nor-Cal

Re: Nick's 1991 200q Project - QUAT44RO

Post by ringbearer »

And back on track... ;)
User avatar
20VAvant
Posts: 370
Joined: Tue Apr 09, 2013 1:47 pm
Location: Florence, KY

Re: Nick's 1991 200q Project - QUAT44RO

Post by 20VAvant »

amd is the best wrote:ANYWAY, this car will be a 3B. We can go back and forth all day but ultimately I wanted to keep the old SHITTY engine with a poor lifter design, pay "TONS" of money to only SLIGHTLY outflow (possibly) the $500 junkyard counterpart and we'll see how my horrible choices pan out. Turbo is probably "too big" too.

For the record, the head didn't cost $6000... To give real rough figures we'll say the parts cost ~$1500 (no CATS) and the labor was ~$1500 and I shopped around for the CATS and scored them at $1000. So I'm around $4000 give or take for a completely built cylinder head with REAL cams (7A's are a joke in comparison). All work was performed by a trusted individual with a reputation to produce reliable performance and longevity. I would have paid double for the labor knowing that it was done correctly.


:thumbsup:
-2015 Lexus RX350 - Been promoted to dad duty.

-2014 Lexus IS350 - SOLD
-2015 Yamaha FZ-07 - SOLD
-2005 Honda CRF230F - SOLD
-2002 Dodge Ram 3500 5.9 Cummins 6 Speed - SOLD
-1991 200 20VTQ Avant - VEMS - SOLD
-2008 Dodge Ram 2500 - 6.7 Cummins - SOLD
Hank
Posts: 1718
Joined: Tue Feb 26, 2013 1:16 am

Re: Nick's 1991 200q Project - QUAT44RO

Post by Hank »

That probably wasn't the best dump location for 07k infoz Nick. Sorry about that. I can weed that out.

I think your plan is stellar and done right. You are going to make loads of usable power and have a wicked car. i can't wait for an SFest rip.

Hank
Post Reply